Keeping medicinal pot illegal is dopey

By Sarah Dugan
Updated: 10/26/10 12:40am
  Email this article  |      Share on Delicious  Share on Digg
Tools

Possibly Related

Pot, weed, dope, Mary Jane, Cannabis — marijuana goes by many names. But whatever you want to call it, it is a drug worthy of legalization — at least for medicinal purposes.

In the U.S., medical marijuana legalization is done on a state-by-state basis. So far, 14 states have already legalized the use of medical marijuana — and with good reason.

In California, the big debate is whether or not to legalize marijuana for personal use other than medicinal purposes. But in North Carolina, the bill to legalize it for medicinal purposes has still not passed.

A 2010 report on WebMD compiled studies showing that marijuana is effective for treating a multitude of medical problems. Some of the uses include relieving chronic pain in AIDS patients and patients with spinal cord injuries, as well as relieving muscle spasms in multiple sclerosis patients.

The addictive properties of marijuana are not as perilous as those of other drugs that are legal in our country — alcohol and tobacco.

So with all of this evidence in support of the legalization of medical marijuana, why hasn’t North Carolina been one of the 14 states to legalize it?

In the past few years, North Carolina has tried without success to pass House Bill 1380, which would allow patients suffering from certain medical conditions to legally use medical marijuana with a prescription.

In August 2010, the state’s democratic executive committee passed a resolution supporting the legalization of medical marijuana.

So what can you do as a voter in North Carolina to aid in the legalization of medical marijuana?

The best thing to do is to check whether the candidate you plan to vote for on Nov. 2 supports the House Bill 1380, and if they don’t, write or call and request that they do.

The next question is that of whether it is a good idea to legalize marijuana for purposes other than medical use. This issue is being raised in California elections this year with Proposition 19. If passed, the bill will allow people over 21 to possess, consume, and grow small quantities of taxable marijuana without having a prescription.

The supporters of this bill claim that these taxes would bring money in to the state, while cutting funding for foreign drug cartels and reducing violence due to drug trafficking.

But since the bill would not legalize the mass production of marijuana in the U.S., marijuana consumption would still need to be met by foreign growers.

This is evident in Holland, where large-scale production of marijuana is illegal, despite the fact that small-scale possession, consumption and growing is not penalized for those more than 18 years old. This means that many of the coffee shops selling marijuana still get their product from illegal sources.

In contrast, marijuana grown for medicinal purposes is grown by local dispensaries, so foreign cartels are not involved.

To recap, legalization of marijuana for purposes other than medicinal would be ineffective in reducing foreign drug trade; however, legalization for medical purposes would benefit many chronic pain patients, without creating an out-of-control drug culture.

Sarah Dugan is a columnist from The Daily Tar Heel. She is a senior environmental major from Asheville. Contact her at sdugan@emai.unc.edu

Published October 25, 2010 in Opinion

8 comments

ThatEpicMania
October 26, 2010 at 3:25 AM
Flag this comment

Don’t kid yourself; you didn’t “prove” that legalizing marijuana for recreational use is inherently bad, you proved that governments need to also legalize and regulate production of cannabis plants. The Netherlands demonstrates the failure of a (mostly) legal front policy and illegal back door policy. Think about it; if you can’t mass produce marijuana, where do you think medical dispensaries are getting their cannabis from?


whocares
October 26, 2010 at 11:39 AM
Flag this comment

what a bada**, i’m gonna write an article about marijuana too so i can look very countercultural and progressive. medicinal marijuana is a joke and i’m sure the author knows this (see recent cnn video about medicinal marijuana in cali)


TheTrees
October 26, 2010 at 3:18 PM
Flag this comment

The problem of violence surrounding the trade of marijuana is no mysterious phenomenon. We’re seeing the same effects of draconian laws on our southern border today that our grandparents witnessed on our northern border during prohibition.

I’m all for legalizing medical marijuana but also legalization in general simply because prohibition is destructive, let alone ineffective.

Read more …

I’m not holding my breath for NC though. The prohibitions here only increase, not decrease. Look at what those idiots did to businesses like Hookah Bliss all in the name of health risks. Never mind that it’s wrong to arbitrarily put people out of business.

Sadly, marijuana doesn’t stand a chance here.


Sensibility
October 26, 2010 at 7:34 PM
Flag this comment

Good article, and I really hope to see Prop 19 pass. It’s such a waste of money to put non-violent consumers in prison. It’s a long-shot to see weed legalized in NC, but here’s to hoping!


Thinkaboutwhy
October 27, 2010 at 12:41 PM
Flag this comment

If it’s not medicine, then why does the US government own the patent to several compounds in cannabis that shrinks tumors? The issue is big pharma can’t figure a way to “own” it.
The big joke is I get bombarded on every television channel about some substance that will help some condition that my Dr. is obviously not up to speed on…. and then the disclaimer about how my insides “might” fall out, brain hemorrhage, or perhaps stroke. Same non-critical thinkers that have a big opinion about gun freedom and “Big Government” have blinders on when it comes to the effects of prohibition. The same laws that are bad about the war on drugs, allow your guns to be in jeopardy…. wait, I’m sure I’m giving some a headache. For goodness sake what’s wrong with a “medicine” that’s only bad side effect is feeling euphoric?

I think I’ll go now and drink a fifth of whiskey, for my sore throat….


thunder_head
October 27, 2010 at 5:47 PM
Flag this comment

I think that more money is being made by keeping it e legal.


StormCrow
October 27, 2010 at 6:52 PM
Flag this comment

For 100s of free articles and studies about cannabis as a medicine, run a search for “Granny Storm Crow’s MMJ Reference List”. Educate yourself!


bobdobbolina
October 30, 2010 at 10:28 AM
Flag this comment

A 12yo can go to a 7-11, and buy a COCAINE derivative preparation,(ORA-GEL), meant for use by INFANTS for teething pain.
A dying CANCER patient has to live in CONSTANT fear of MIDNIGHT RAIDS,ARREST,ARMED ROBBERIES,and HARRASSMENT for their ‘LEGAL’ use of MEDICAL CANNABIS!

 
Join the discussion
You Should Know

The Daily Tar Heel reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.

If this is the first time you've commented, your comment won't appear until you've verified your email address.

Formatting Options:
  • Links: "my link":http://my.url.com
  • Bold: *something!*
  • Italic: _OMG!_
Powered by Detroit Softworks