URL: http://www.dailytarheel.com/index.php/article/2010/11/protest_with_a_happy_ending_
Current Date: Thu, 24 May 2012 02:31:18 -0400
Students walking through the Pit last week might have noticed a cube painted by the men’s club ice hockey team. The cube advertised the team’s participation in a tournament and featured a drawing of a busty woman and the tag line, “Come watch us score.”
Members of Feminist Students United took offense to the cube. They painted another side of it, expressing their opinions about the derogatory nature of the hockey team’s advertisement.
The strategy the leaders of Feminist Students United used to deal with the advertisement they found offensive helped to turn those statements into constructive conversation.
It would have been really easy for members of Feminist Students United to sabotage the hockey advertisement by painting over it. Outrageous imagery doesn’t always evoke a measured response.
But by painting their own cube, Feminist Students United enhanced the debate in a meaningful way. Offensive messages are a voice against themselves.
Calling attention to it rather than covering it up allowed the community to have a thoughtful debate.
This is how protests should be done.
Painting over offensive messages, as is the practice with the NC State free expression tunnel, doesn’t make them go away. Messages need to be delivered to be discussed. An offensive message cannot discredit itself if it is censored.
It didn’t take long for the hockey team to apologize for the cube and offer to take steps to make up for it.
Events like this are why public forums exist.
Last week’s cube incident was a victory for the First Amendment.
It is encouraging to see students act in ways that show respect for and understanding of public debate.
Do you think fracking can be done safely?
I certainly agree with the sentiment that Feminist Students United took the right approach with their side of the cube (although I wish it were a little less inflammatory and a little more informative), but I do think the Hockey players deserve credit for quickly recognizing their mistake and rectifying it as well as taking measures to educate themselves on this topic. I think it shows quite a bit more maturity and sensitivity than some feminists would be willing to give our athletes for them to own up to this error in judgment and genuinely apologize on multiple fronts.
While I am sincerely appreciative of the apology given by the UNC men’s hockey team and the outpouring support of the Feminist Student’s United brilliant painted cube response I can’t help but consider: where does UNC go from here? Do we pretend that the incident of an offensively painted cube with a sexual double entendre was an isolated case of ‘boys will be boys’ and scapegoat the hockey team for being insensitive? Or do we make the conscious decision to have the tough and necessary conversation and ask ourselves: what is the environment that we as members of the UNC community are creating? Is it one of equality, mutual respect and understanding, a safe and healthy place for all? Unfortunately through my experience and education I can attest this is not always the case. In a world where one derogatory remark about a member of the queer community is too many, one insensitive joke about rape or gendered violence is too many, one sexual is assault is far too many, we as a university have a long way to go. Yet I remain hopeful. I see inspiring actions from UNC students who are sick of the status quo every day. Imagine: a community where we are held accountable to one another, where we feel a sense responsibility to one another, a community that demands to be better, because we can be. One of the most empowering experiences I have been lucky to have recently was attending ‘One Act’, an active bystander education training that teaches students how to successfully intervene to prevent interpersonal violence. This model depends on the idea that if even one person takes just one action, their society may be improved. So I urge UNC students to not shrug their shoulders and walk away when they see displays such as the one the hockey team painted last week. Take the time to question where messages like those stem from, why they are dangerous, and what role can we all potentially play in crafting a UNC environment as it could and should be.
The Daily Tar Heel reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.
If this is the first time you've commented, your comment won't appear until you've verified your email address.
Flag this comment