North Carolina legislature considers hydraulic fracturing

By Memet Walker
Updated: 09/20/11 12:51am
  Email this article  |      Share on Delicious  Share on Digg
Tools

 
Possibly Related

A new method of energy gathering is creating friction among legislators and environmental activist in North Carolina.

The state could soon be entering a new era in energy if state legislators override Gov. Bev Perdue’s veto of a bill that would open the state to hydraulic fracturing, also known as “fracking.”

Fracking releases natural gas trapped in rock deep beneath the ground by pumping a highly pressurized water mixture up to thousands of feet beneath the soil to break up the rock and allows natural gas to escape to the surface.

Sen. Tommy Tucker, R-Mecklenburg, sponsored the bill, the Energy Jobs Act, that would open up the state to fracking.

“It is going to create high paying jobs in parts of the state that desperately need it,” Tucker said.

But the bill was vetoed by Perdue in June. The Senate has already overridden the veto, but the House has not.

Tucker said it might take another election cycle before the House can find the votes to overcome the veto.

“I just don’t understand why anyone would want to depend on the Middle East for energy,” he said.

The Senate recently commissioned the N.C. Department of Environment and Natural Resources to conduct a study to examine the potential effects of fracking in the state. The study is expected to be completed in April 2012.

The technology for fracking is not new. The state is following in the footsteps of others that are already open to fracking, said Rick Bolich, a hydrogeologist with the department.

However, North Carolina is geologically different than other states, he said.

“We can see what’s been done in other parts of the country,” Bolich said. “Certainly there have been mistakes made, and we can try and keep those mistakes from happening here.”

But those mistakes are a big concern for local environmentalists, who said the costs of fracking far outweigh its possible benefits.

The amount of water used in fracking is a cause for alarm, said Katie Hicks, assistant director of Clean Water for North Carolina.

“At drought time, it can be devastating, since the process uses such huge amounts of water,” she said. “Anything that we can do to conserve the water for people is really going to be more and more essential.”

But Tucker said he thinks fracking, if adopted in the state, would cease during a drought.

Hicks also said the process might contaminate groundwater, which is used for drinking water.

The water mixture used to break up rock contains a small amount of chemicals that could leak and contaminate the state’s aquifers, she said.

“There’s a specific concern for groundwater here, especially since there are so many groundwater (well) users in North Carolina,” she said.

So far, Hicks said she has been pleased by the public response to Clean Water’s fight against the bill.

“In general, the response has been pretty astounding,” she said.

Jose Rial, a professor of geophysics and climatology at UNC, said he doesn’t like the idea either.

Even though only small amounts of chemicals are used in the process, supporters of fracking shouldn’t dismiss the potential dangers, he said.

“That’s like saying Kools are good for you because they taste like mint,” Rial said.

But Tucker said possible contamination by chemicals used in fracking should not deter the process.

“Regrettably, if it happens, it happens,” he said. “When you have a crash, you don’t stop flying.

“We’ll continually improve the process.”

Contact the State & National Editor at state@dailytarheel.com.

Published September 15, 2011 in State

7 comments

Jameson Lopp
September 16, 2011 at 8:17 AM
Flag this comment

Watch the documentary “Gasland” and you’ll have a much better understanding of why hydraulic fracking is a process that should be outright illegal.


Hugo
September 16, 2011 at 9:05 AM
Flag this comment

“Watch the documentary “Gasland” and you’ll have a much better understanding of why hydraulic fracking is a process that should be outright illegal.”

Translation: Watch the agenda driven documentary “Gasland” and you will be herded like sheep to a particular viewpoint. I am incapable of forming my own thoughts or opinions and rely on others to do it for me.

Read more …

This would be a great opportunity for our state that would be beneficial to everyone. We need to be focused on jobs not a knee-jerk environmentalist reaction. By opposing this you are keeping people out of work. Don’t deprive others of an employment opportunity.


Colin Dodd
September 16, 2011 at 9:46 AM
Flag this comment

Hugo, does your comment mean that the waste water from fracking is not toxic? How do you know that? Aren’t you just believing what you are being told? Are you a geologist? Are you even studying geology? Are you a chemist? Are you a hydrologist or an drilling engineer? How are you qualified to say that it’s safe. What are your credentials? You might have more luck in persuading people if you stop insulting them and explain why you have any credibility.


Nipsop
September 16, 2011 at 11:11 AM
Flag this comment

It’s North Carolina, home of the low information folks, the home of an amendment against gay marriage, why wouldn’t this become standard practice?


Hugo
September 16, 2011 at 11:25 AM
Flag this comment

Hugo, does your comment mean that the waste water from fracking is not toxic? How do you know that? Aren’t you just believing what you are being told? Are you a geologist? Are you even studying geology? Are you a chemist? Are you a hydrologist or an drilling engineer? How are you qualified to say that it’s safe. What are your credentials?

Why don’t you direct those questions to Jameson Lopp and Governor Perdue? Do you really think she is these things? Of course not yet, she vetoes it.

Read more …

Fact: This would bring much needed jobs to NC and boost our economy.

Assumption: This would hurt our drinking water.

I deal with facts, you deal with off-chance assumptions. You can’t refute that this would boost our economy.


Bauregard
September 16, 2011 at 1:32 PM
Flag this comment

Hugo said:
“Don’t deprive others of an employment opportunity.”
but depriving them of clean water and air is ok? The fact that the majority of jobs will go to oil and gas professionals from Texas and Colorado aside, why should people sacrifice their health and their homes so that gas comps can get rich? You are probably an industry troll, but if you aren’t – go read up on what has happened to people in TX and PA that trusted the frackers.


JWW
September 16, 2011 at 2:16 PM
Flag this comment

“Even though only small amounts of chemicals are used in the process, supporters of fracking shouldn’t dismiss the potential dangers, he said.

“That’s like saying Kools are good for you because they taste like mint,” Rial said.

Read more …

Can anyone please explain the analogy between Kools, mints, fracking and how it makes sense with this article?

I don’t think that anyone who is in support of fracking to recover natural gas is unaware of potential risks. It is (as always) about managing risks, otherwise a person would never leave their house.

To Colin: I’m going to be clever now and use your words against you.

Aren’t you Colin just believing what Colin is being told? Colin, are yoiu a geologist? Colin, are you even studying geology? Colin, are you a chemist? Colin, are you a hydrologist or an drilling engineer? How are you Colin qualified to say that it’s NOT safe. What are your credentials? Colin, you might have more luck in persuading people if you stop insulting them and explain why you have any credibility just by watching the discredited Gasland.

 
Join the discussion
You Should Know

The Daily Tar Heel reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.

If this is the first time you've commented, your comment won't appear until you've verified your email address.

Formatting Options:
  • Links: "my link":http://my.url.com
  • Bold: *something!*
  • Italic: _OMG!_
Powered by Detroit Softworks