College Media Network

Congress launches ethics inquiry

Dispute over group’s funding request

Hillary Rose Owens, Staff Writer

Elly Schofield, Staff Writer

Print this article

Published: Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Updated: Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Congress

dth/Alexandra Brawley

Senior Shaniqua McClendon asks Student Congress for forgiveness.

Conflicting stories

Student Congress will investigate whether the Concept of Colors’ treasurer, Shaniqua McClendon, exaggerated the group’s financial needs.

The modeling group’s $7,535 funding request is in question after Congress representatives heard that McClendon overstated the group’s need from students in a class with her.

The group planned to use the money to buy costumes for fashion shows.

McClendon testified to Congress that she had forgotten to complete an assignment for a business class. The assignment required her to bargain with a store worker to lower a sale price or to tell a story about a similar negotiation.

On the spot, she said she used last week’s Congress finance committee meeting — where she first made the funding request — as an example of a time when she successfully bargained for more than she needed, saying that she expected the committee to cut the money significantly.

“It was mostly the way it was presented that made it seem like it was not true information,” McClendon said.

“I don’t remember exactly what I said, but I don’t think I implied that I just pulled numbers out of thin air.”

McClendon’s professor, Adam Grant, and at least two of her classmates informed Congress of what McClendon had said.

Though McClendon assured Congress that she had been truthful with them last week, many Congress members raised doubts about the validity of the request.

“It’s our obligation to fund in the most economical way possible,” said representative Harrison Brooks.

“If we were to pass this, we would be relinquishing all of our power and duty to the students.”

Congress voted to table the funding bill until the ethics committee reviews what happened.

Charissa Lloyd, the ethics committee’s chairwoman, said the committee will look at the conflicting stories and decide if McClendon embellished the request to Congress.

“We would like to give the group a chance to defend themselves,” she said.

She also said Congress will look into ways to better scrutinize funding requests to prevent similar incidents in the future.

“We would like to see how the finance committee can better investigate the numbers given by any group, not just this group,” Lloyd said.

Mike Morrill, chairman of the finance committee, said the group’s request seemed reasonable at last week’s finance committee meeting.

McClendon’s actions also could have academic consequences.

Deputy Undergraduate Student Attorney General Andrew Pham said the usual sanction for academic dishonesty is one semester suspension with a minimum sanction of one semester probation.

McClendon said she did not find out until about 6 p.m. Tuesday that Congress had questions about the request.

Visibly emotional at the Congress meeting, McClendon said she regretted her actions.

“It was dumb,” she said. “I shouldn’t have done it.”



Contact the University Editor at udesk@unc.edu.

Comments

5 comments
The Chief Justice
Thu Oct 9 2008 01:00
Getthe truth,

My original comments were made several hours before Ms. McClendon commented on this story. I also appreciate her apparent honesty. Frankly, I refuse to "stay out of the situation" because, as a student who pays student fees, I have a right to know where my money goes and I want to make sure none of it is wasted or exploited. I will also be the first to admit that I have made the mistake of lying before, however, I was force to pay the consequences for my faulty judgment, which I hope will happen in this case if the ethics committee deems it necessary.

Getthe truth
Wed Oct 8 2008 23:43
Since you obviously did not understand her apology letter--let me break it down for you.
Shaniqua did not do the assignment and so she made something up on the spot. The first thing that she could think of was to make something up, yes, she lied. She made up a completely FALSE story about getting more money from Congress than she needed---she lied about getting more money in order to complete the assignment.
She claimed otherwise in class because she made an irresponsible decision, as she so stated in her apology letter, instead of just saying that she did not have the assigment, she made something up.
Because in all of your years of living I am absolutely positively sure that you have never lied before....but, she should not have lied to begin with...you know that, I know that, but most importantly she knows that (As she so stated in her letter above).
So I think that you should stay out of the situation since you clearly have no knowledge of what is going on.
Shaniqua McClendon
Wed Oct 8 2008 05:17
Good Morning Everyone,

If I would have been told that me not doing an assignment would have turned into this I would have not even tried to turn it in.

Regardless of that I would just like to apologize to mostly the student body for what appears to be an attempt to use student fees in an unethical manner. Just like all of you I am a student as well and do not want my fees to be wasted on arbitrary things. Secondly I would like to apologize to student congress. In no way did I intend to make anyone look silly in this entire process or appear that I was bragging in front of a class about being deceitful. I also want to apologize to my class and professor for being dishonest during class. Lastly l want to apologize to every student organization member that I represent in any capacity. As a leader at UNC, I should have fully thought about the consequences of my actions.

I know many of you will form whatever opinion you choose, but if you have any questions please feel free to contact me and I will answer them.

* Professor Adam Grant was not one of the individuals who contacted student congress.

Shaniqua McClendon

The Chief Justice
Wed Oct 8 2008 01:58
If, at 6:19, Ms. McClendon contacted Mr. Nichols saying the allegations were not true, then why did claim otherwise in her class. Was she lying then or is she lying now.
The Chief Justice
Wed Oct 8 2008 01:56
If these allegations are determined to be true during the inquiry, the organization should receive no funding and Ms. McClendon should be personally reprimanded. I would also expect a public letter of apology to the student body who contributes to the Student Activity Fee budget.

Log in to be able to post comments.