Incumbent Edith Wiggins prevailed with the most votes. Newcomers Dorothy Verkerk, Ed Harrison and Mark Kleinschmidt also won seats on the council, according to unofficial returns.
"I'm really grateful to the citizens for re-electing me," Wiggins said. "It speaks about support."
Dorothy Verkerk placed second and said her support kicked up once her campaign got rolling.
"It was a humbling experience to have so many people believe in me," Verkerk said.
Verkerk, an art history professor at UNC, said she plans to place the University's concerns high on her agenda.
"I care deeply about the University," Verkerk said. "One of the things that I really understand is the University's transportation needs."
Verkerk said a big issue that she will address is the creation of better public transportation in Chapel Hill.
Ed Harrison, who received the third largest number of votes, also emphasized his plans to focus on transportation as a council member.
"One thing I want to get involved in quite soon is regional transportation," Harrison said. "We have a real chance to move ahead in transportation."