The Daily Tar Heel
Printing news. Raising hell. Since 1893.
Friday, April 19, 2024 Newsletters Latest print issue

We keep you informed.

Help us keep going. Donate Today.
The Daily Tar Heel

Aniston Shocks Old Fans With 'Good Girl'

"The Good Girl"

Justine Last, the simple-living heroine of the new film "The Good Girl," is a lot different than Rachel Green, the beauty queen mainstay of the hit TV series "Friends."

In her continued effort to gain respect on the silver screen, actress Jennifer Aniston gives a performance that carries absolutely no vestiges of her famous television persona.

Justine lives in a small Texas town, where she spends her days manning the cosmetics counter at a local drugstore. At night, she dreams of escaping her marriage to her house-painting, pot-smoking husband Phil (John C. Reilly).

Her existence is thrown into disarray after she meets fellow drugstore worker Holden (Jake Gyllenhaal), a brooding writer who fancies himself the next J. D. Salinger. Justine hopes that he can send a few waves through the monotony of her life.

Once they get involved via clandestine motel meetings and storeroom trysts, she finds herself further entangled when her husband's best friend, Bubba, (Tim Blake Nelson of "O Brother, Where Art Thou?") finds out about her secret activities.

While all of these events keep the pace plodding along and employ some interesting twists along the way, "The Good Girl" is a character study at its core. All the actors, especially Aniston, pull it off flawlessly.

Justine makes a series of bad choices during the course of the film. Aniston's involving performance makes Justine's experimentation and frantic attempts to cover her tracks both believable and compelling.

Her ultimate mistake was latching onto Holden, a ticking time bomb of insecurity and angst. Jake Gyllenhaal does an admirable job of sketching out his character, but there's still something lacking.

This void could partially be the fault of the screenwriters, who give Holden an alcoholic past and other troubles with little necessary explanation or elaboration. The writing was mostly tight and complex, but gaps nevertheless have remained and several twists can be seen coming from miles away.

Another critical element was missing from the writing -- specifically, it's difficult to put one's finger on the point of the movie.

The story cannot decide whether it wants to condone or condemn Justine's actions, and the ending doesn't do anything to clear that up.

But at the same time, Aniston's choice for a career-changing vehicle isn't so far-out. With a great turn by Zooey Deschanel as a wacky cosmetics worker and many darkly comic moments, "The Good Girl" is funnier than expected.

If Aniston can find more projects that combine her dramatic and comedic strengths as well as "The Good Girl," then she needn't worry about her career once "Friends" ends in May.

The Arts & Entertainment Editor can be reached at artsdesk@unc.edu.

To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.