• Campus
    • Campus
    • Student Life
    • Administration
    • Faculty
    • Higher Education
  • City & County
    • City & County
    • Chapel Hill
    • Carrboro
    • Education
    • Public Safety
  • Politics
    • Politics
    • North Carolina
    • National
  • Sports
    • Sports
    • Football
    • Men's Basketball
    • Women's Basketball
    • Cross Country
    • Golf
    • Men's Soccer
    • Women's Soccer
    • Swimming and Diving
    • Men's Tennis
    • Women's Tennis
    • Field Hockey
    • Rowing
    • Volleyball
  • Culture
    • Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Food
  • Opinion
    • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Cartoons
    • Columns
    • Letters
    • Kvetching Board
  • Multimedia
    • Multimedia
    • Video
    • Galleries
    • Audio
  • About
    • About
    • Hiring
    • Board of Directors
    • Alumni
    • Corrections
    • Contact
    • Meet the editors
    • Policies & Bylaws
  • Advertise
    • Advertise
    • Policies
    • Events Calendar
    • Celebrations
    • Obituaries
  • Donate
  • Story Collections

  • HeelsHousing
  • Offline Chapel Hill
  • Shop
  • Buy Photos
  • 1893 Brand Studio
  • Alumni
  • Events Calendar
  • Celebrations/Obits
    • Celebrations
    • Obituaries
  • Southern Neighbor
  • Newsletter
  • Classifieds
  • Campus
  • City & County
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Culture
  • Opinion
  • Donate
  • HeelsHousing
  • Search
The Daily Tar Heel

Serving the students and the University community since 1893.

The Daily Tar Heel
    • Campus
      • Campus
      • Student Life
      • Administration
      • Faculty
      • Higher Education
    • City & County
      • City & County
      • Chapel Hill
      • Carrboro
      • Education
      • Public Safety
    • Politics
      • Politics
      • North Carolina
      • National
    • Sports
      • Sports
      • Football
      • Men's Basketball
      • Women's Basketball
      • Cross Country
      • Golf
      • Men's Soccer
      • Women's Soccer
      • Swimming and Diving
      • Men's Tennis
      • Women's Tennis
      • Field Hockey
      • Rowing
      • Volleyball
    • Culture
      • Culture
      • Arts & Entertainment
      • Food
    • Opinion
      • Opinion
      • Editorials
      • Cartoons
      • Columns
      • Letters
      • Kvetching Board
    • Multimedia
      • Multimedia
      • Video
      • Galleries
      • Audio
    • About
      • About
      • Hiring
      • Board of Directors
      • Alumni
      • Corrections
      • Contact
      • Meet the editors
      • Policies & Bylaws
    • Advertise
      • Advertise
      • Policies
      • Events Calendar
      • Celebrations
      • Obituaries
    • Donate
    • Story Collections

    • HeelsHousing
    • Offline Chapel Hill
    • Shop
    • Buy Photos
    • 1893 Brand Studio
    • Alumni
    • Events Calendar
    • Celebrations/Obits
      • Celebrations
      • Obituaries
    • Southern Neighbor
    • Newsletter
    • Classifieds
  • In the News
  • Men's basketball
  • The OC Report
  • Football
  • Business
  • Franklin Street

2/20/2019, 9:10pm

UNC stats class finds 1,500 unaccounted absentee ballots in NC 9th District election

UNC stats class finds 1,500 unaccounted absentee ballots in NC 9th District election Buy Photos
Republican Mark Harris, left, and his attorney David Freedman speak with the media after meeting with state election investigators on Thursday, Jan. 3, 2019 at the Dobbs Building in Raleigh, N.C. (Ethan Hyman/Raleigh News & Observer/TNS)

Share

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Mail
  • Print
BY Evely Forte

A UNC statistics class analyzed data from the most recent 2018 North Carolina general election and found that more than 1,500 absentee ballots were unaccounted for in Bladen and Robeson counties, which are part of North Carolina’s 9th Congressional District. 

Richard Smith, distinguished professor in the Department of Statistics and Operations Research, teaches the approximately 70-student class of STOR 556, “Advanced Methods of Data Analysis” and had students analyze election data from all 100 North Carolina counties. 

“It started out as a homework exercise,” Smith said. “There was an example in the text which was about the election results from the Bush v. Gore election, which is 19 years ago, and I said to the students, ‘Why are we talking about this example that is 19 years old when we have lots of data right here? There is an argument going on in North Carolina.' So I went online, downloaded some data and made it a homework exercise. I wanted to see what students would make of it.” 

The basis of Smith’s assignment revolved around the undecided election of Republican candidate Mark Harris for the U.S. House in North Carolina’s 9th Congressional District.

Harris won the election in November 2018 by 905 votes over Democrat Dan McCready, but the North Carolina State Board of Elections refused to certify his election after doubts arose concerning the legitimacy of the results due to fraudulent practices with absentee ballots. The State Board of Elections held a hearing this week about these allegations of fraud. 


Editors Picks

‘We have made progress’: How UNC has advanced women on campus this past decade


Here's how studying has evolved throughout the decade


The Campaign for Carolina initiative allowed for fundraising growth over the decade



The Board could order a new election if the 9th Congressional District ballots aren't certified.

“One of the issues is, can we actually prove that the number of missing votes was greater than 905?” Smith said. 

Smith said he collected data of the number of absentee ballots for all 100 counties in North Carolina. He then found the proportion of absentee ballots that were not returned was less than 4 percent for 98 counties, slightly higher than the usual 1 to 2 percent rate, and around 11 percent in both Bladen and Robeson counties. 

Students were first instructed to create a linear model for all 100 counties. 

Rachel Allen, a senior in Smith's class, said it was obvious on the graphs and modeling she created that of all the counties, Bladen and Robeson counties were outliers. 

Smith then had students create a linear model, without Bladen and Robeson counties, to predict the number of absentee ballots that should have not been returned for the two counties given various demographic variables and data from the other 98 counties under normal circumstances. The class then compared the estimates to the number of ballots they had found that were actually unaccounted for in Bladen and Robeson counties last November.  

“If you look at what we found, it is basically impossible for these two counties to have the number of unaccounted for absentee ballots that they do (without intervention)," said Michael Quint, a junior in Smith's class.

The class findings suggest that more than 1,500 ballots were not accounted for this past election. They report that data with a 99 percent confidence interval, which is a 99 percent confidence level, Smith said.

Smith said the point of doing the calculation is to show that 1,500 is greater than 905 so it proves this fraud could have changed the results of the election. 

“We don’t have any means of knowing whose votes were intended for the Republican or Democrat, but what the suggestion in the hearings is that there was someone going around collecting ballots and systematically removed all the ballots for the Democrat candidate,” Smith said.

Smith had sent an earlier version of his findings to the North Carolina State Board of Elections this past January. After reviewing the findings of his students in his class this semester and adding in some of their findings, he revised his paper and submitted it to the Board again. He has not received a response.

The Daily Tar Heel contacted the North Carolina State Board of Elections for comment. At time of publication, the DTH had not received a response.

“Professor Smith wasn't doing anything explicitly political with his paper besides just stating that there was something odd going on,” Quint said. “But I think through that work he was able to cement that and help with furthering the investigation to prove what was happening.” 

university@dailytarheel.com


Next up in Student Life

  • Student Government hosts workshop featuring professional lobbyists and state senator

  • 'It’s totally surreal': UNC's fourth astronaut graduate recalls her path to NASA

  • From holiday gifts to clothing lines: How UNC students use BeAM makerspaces


Next up in Campus

  • Activists protested the BOG at meeting where Guskiewicz was appointed chancellor

  • Kevin Guskiewicz named UNC's 12th permanent chancellor

  • N.C. Attorney General calls Silent Sam trust 'excessive' as lawyers raise concerns


Next up in UNC-Chapel Hill

  • How 10 years of crime and public safety incidents affected the Chapel Hill community

  • North Carolina Museum of History exhibit celebrates 200 years of the NC Supreme Court

  • This UNC grad and former vegetarian created a pork company focused on sustainability


Next up in N.C. Board of Elections


Next up in North Carolina Politics

  • How partisanship has changed North Carolina's budget process in the last decade

  • How the Republican takeover of the General Assembly changed the UNC System

  • 'Victory': Confederates tout backdoor dealings of $2.5 million Silent Sam settlement


The Daily Tar Heel welcomes thoughtful discussion on all of our stories, but please keep comments civil and on-topic.

Latest Print Edition

Print Edition Print Archive

Decade in Review

Special Print Edition

Start the Presses!

Thank you for reading! You are someone who appreciates independent student journalism, support that work with your tax-deductible donation today!

Donate Now!
    • Front Page
    • Campus
    • City & County
    • Politics
    • Sports
    • Culture
    • Opinion
    • Donate
    • HeelsHousing
Daily Tar Heel To Homepage
109 E. Franklin St. Suite 210, Chapel Hill, NC 27514
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Shop
  • Buy Photos
  • 1893 Brand Studio
  • Alumni
  • Events Calendar
  • Celebrations/Obituaries
  • Southern Neighbor
  • Offline Chapel Hill
  • Newsletter
  • RSS
  • Classifieds

All Rights Reserved

© Copyright 2019 The Daily Tar Heel

Powered by Solutions by The State News.

A Century of Champions

The perfect gift for the UNC fan in your life. Celebrate UNC basketball's years of success with "A Century of Champions," a keepsake poster from The Daily Tar Heel and 1893 Brand Studio.

Buy Now