They called themselves members of the “underground bunker.”
It was a group of faculty members of color that included American studies professor Sharon Holland and others she did not name. Holland said they met every two weeks in the basement of Provost Bob Blouin’s office while it was being redecorated during the summer of 2019.
It was exhausting, she said, to meet during summer hours without pay.
Blouin assembled the ad hoc committee to discuss diversity, equity and inclusion at the University — laying some of the groundwork for strategic initiatives that would become part of the Carolina Next plan. The first of the plan’s eight initiatives, called Build Our Community Together, focuses on DEI at UNC.
“Even though we weren’t really sure what we could count on from leadership, we were stepping up in good faith and giving our time,” Holland said.
That work continued into the pandemic, when professors Kia Caldwell and Malinda Maynor-Lowery authored the “Roadmap for Racial Equity,” a plan that called for sustainable action on DEI over the course of three years. Holland signed it, alongside many faculty members of color.
Though Holland still works at UNC, the same cannot be said for other faculty of color who are leaving the University following the UNC Board of Trustees’ initial decision to not offer tenure to Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Nikole Hannah-Jones.
For many faculty of color, the breaking point came before they knew Hannah-Jones might teach at UNC.
Caldwell and Lowery announced their departures this month. Caldwell will join Washington University in St. Louis as its vice provost for faculty affairs and diversity. Lowery will join Emory University's history department.
Holland herself contemplated leaving the University nearly two years ago.
“What does it mean that two of the three people who were very visible in the Roadmap for Racial Equity have left the University?”
When Annette Rodríguez was in discussions with the University of Texas at Austin this year, she realized they had an interest in her work that she didn’t feel at UNC.
Rodríguez joined UNC in 2018 as a recipient of the Carolina Postdoctoral Fellowship for Faculty Diversity. She said she chose to come to UNC to have time for her own research and for the opportunity to become a tenure track faculty member.
Rodríguez, who was an assistant professor of American Studies at UNC, said she’d been asked about other things — such as teaching Latinx curriculum and advising on committees about race, queerness or hate crimes.
“But I’d literally not had discussions about my actual research, and I didn’t know that really,” she said. “I was also just exhausted.”
When it came time to retain her from being recruited away, Rodríguez said, it was Holland and Lowery who were working to put together an offer, rather than University administrators. To Rodríguez, this retention process was another example of faculty of color at UNC being overburdened.
“I realized that the institution had replicated the problem, which is that a Black woman and an indigenous woman were working very hard to keep a Latinx woman,” she said.
Rodríguez is an incoming assistant professor at UT Austin's department of history.
In a written statement, UNC Media Relations noted the Carolina Postdoctoral Program for Faculty Diversity and the Build Our Community Together strategic initiative as two of the University’s efforts to recruit and retain diverse faculty. They also noted the Targeting Equity in Access to Mentoring (TEAM) ADVANCE program and the Valuing Inclusion To Attain Excellence (VITAE) initiative, which supports recruitment of faculty members from underrepresented groups for tenure track or tenured appointments.
Of UNC's 4,085 faculty members in fall 2020, 226 were Black or African American, 460 were Asian and 201 were Hispanic of any race, according to data from the UNC Office of Institutional Research & Assessment. About 73 percent — 2,997 faculty members — were white.
OIRA defined “faculty” as full-time permanent employees with a primary appointment as faculty and a valid academic rank and tenure status of tenured, tenure track or fixed term in the HR information system.
‘If you ignore a problem, it doesn’t go away’
Associate professor Trevy McDonald is the only Black woman in the Hussman School of Journalism and Media to hold tenure. She was also the first — in 2018.
McDonald said there were no Black women faculty when she was a doctoral student at the journalism school in the 1990s.
“I wanted to have the opportunity one day to give back,” McDonald said. “And that dream was realized 15 years later, when I became a tenure track faculty member at the journalism school.”
McDonald also serves as the director of diversity, equity and inclusion for the journalism school, a position that began in the summer of 2020. As the news about Hannah-Jones’ tenure case unfolded, McDonald could see that it was “very clearly an equity issue.”
She said it was reflective of the same equity issues the University has had for over 50 years.
And to address those issues, McDonald said, the University needs to be intentional with its DEI efforts.
“Being intentional requires that we listen, it requires that we address these issues head-on because that's the only way we're going to grow,” she said. “If you ignore a problem, it doesn't go away. It gets bigger.”
The number of faculty of color who are considering leaving is growing. In a June 16 virtual Carolina Black Caucus meeting, 70 percent of attendees answered a Zoom poll saying they were considering leaving UNC. More than 60 percent were actively seeking other jobs. The organization is composed of Black faculty, staff, graduate and professional students and postdocs.
Chancellor Kevin Guskiewicz subsequently met with leaders of the Carolina Black Caucus and Student Government to address their concerns.
“It has always been my goal to build a community where everyone truly knows they belong and are valued for their own unique perspectives and experiences,” Guskiewicz said in a written statement to The Daily Tar Heel. “I am deeply concerned that some members of the Carolina Black community do not feel they can thrive in this environment.”
Patricia Harris, vice chairperson of the Carolina Black Caucus, said UNC leadership needs to show up for the Black community because what happened with Nikole Hannah-Jones’ fight for tenure is not an isolated incident.
“We constantly see the goalpost that keeps moving when it comes to how Black people find success at PWIs or historically white institutions — places like Carolina,” Harris said.
Even if the Board of Trustees votes to approve Hannah-Jones’ tenure application on Wednesday, it won’t erase long-standing issues that have plagued the University.
For Harris, Holland and Rodríguez, as for many faculty of color, Hannah-Jones' situation was not a surprise.
But it was a disappointment. It was disheartening. It was a sign that there’s more work to be done.
“I don’t think this is what BIPOC faculty feel, but I think too many faculty, maybe, on this campus, feel that if we can turn around Nikole Hannah-Jones’ tenure, everything will be righted at UNC,” Holland said. “This is a fiction.”
To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.