The Daily Tar Heel
Printing news. Raising hell. Since 1893.
Thursday, Feb. 29, 2024 Newsletters Latest print issue

We keep you informed.

Help us keep going. Donate Today.
The Daily Tar Heel

Editorial: Policing is not the solution to traffic safety crisis

Pedestrians cross the crosswalk on W Franklin Street on Monday, Feb. 14, 2022.

Chapel Hill is facing an unparalleled traffic safety crisis. In the last several months, accidents — especially those involving pedestrians or cyclists — have captured local attention.

On Feb. 4, a biker died in the hospital after being struck by a parked vehicle on Franklin Street. Last month, a vehicle crashed into Northside Elementary's playground, injuring three children. In January alone, Chapel Hill saw five different bicycle and pedestrian crashes.

Not only are these instances tragic, but they are also preventable. But when we seek solutions to traffic safety, it is crucial that our solutions are policy- and infrastructure-oriented — not based in policing.

So often are traffic stops, tickets and fines and high-visibility policing considered viable solutions to what happens on our roads. While enforcement of traffic laws is important, it does little to prevent violations.

Ticketing and fines are merely attempts at retribution for harms that have already taken place, and classist ones at that. In response to recent traffic accidents, the Town implemented up to $300 in fines for failure to yield.

A few hundred dollars is a due that might be unjustly damaging to a low-income driver, yet not nearly as impactful for those of higher socioeconomic status.

Traffic stops raise issues on the basis of racial discrimination in policing. Data from "Suspect Citizens: What 20 Million Traffic Stops Tell Us About Policing and Race" — a book that presents data from traffic stops in North Carolina — shows Black drivers are 63 percent more likely to be pulled over than their white counterparts, despite driving 16 percent less.

Similarly, Black drivers were 115 percent more likely to be searched in the event of a traffic stop.

In a similar vein, high visibility policing has the potential to create a hostile community environment, especially for communities disproportionately targeted by police.

Our bike and pedestrian infrastructure should be created with human error in mind. There is no way to completely eliminate accidents on the road, but our city can be crafted in a way that prepares for the potential for such accidents without perpetuating the harms of policing and criminal justice in our own community.

In an op-ed submitted to The Daily Tar Heel, master of science candidate Andrew Zalesak posed thoughtful solutions to this ongoing crisis, including strategic land use planning and the expansion of public transportation as a means of reducing the amount of cars on the road entirely.

Zalesak highlights the negligence of community leaders in taking appropriate action to create spaces that value, protect and dignify bikers and pedestrians from the dangers of vehicle traffic.

"Neither of these crashes was intentional — humans err — but the simple truth is that people driving 3,000-pound metal machines are driving potentially lethal weapons and that the deadliness increases with speed," Zalesak wrote.

Lowering speed limits, installing speed bumps, expanding sidewalks and bike lanes, making well lit and clearly marked crossings and creating public education campaigns are all solutions that don’t give teeth to the ways that the legal system preys on Black, Indigenous and other people of color and poor people.

Investment into these infrastructural changes — and the community members that voice them as solutions — is key.


To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.