Cameron said he grew tired of customers gushing over the merchandise in his store while being unable to purchase it. So as it became harder to sell local crafts, he gradually began to introduce manufactured goods.
"The customers didn't mind the mix," Cameron said.
It is this bizarre mix that defines Cameron's today.
The shop still sells high-end pottery and jewelry, especially from local artists. Shoppers can also find stuffed animal head mounts, candles, handbags and an entire room full of cards.
Quan Nguyen of Chapel Hill has been to Cameron's several times.
"The merchandise here is just very cool; a lot of stuff is different every time I come," Nguyen said.
"If anything, I just like to browse around."
That is the kind of thing Cameron said he likes to hear. He attributes the store's almost 30 years of success to putting the customer's experience first.
"What's important is that when people come in, they feel good - the music they hear, what they see, their interactions," Cameron said.
"When you have that, the sales seem to take care of themselves."
Smith said she believes Cameron's has found a niche in Chapel Hill because of its willingness to adapt to a changing clientele, and the store's proximity to the University.
"You can buy a gift for five dollars if that's all you can spend," she said.
To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.
Students constitute an important part of the store's clientele. It isn't that students necessarily spend a lot of money in the shop, but that they introduce others to the store, Smith said.
"We view everyone as an important customer, even the little 4 -year-old who comes in here and buys a plastic monkey for 10 cents for their room," she said.
One of the unique features of the store is a "shrine room," a small room upstairs with altars.
"It's been there maybe seven or eight years," Thomas said. "It was originally intended as a place where nothing was for sale. You're in a mall, where everything is for sale, and it's really nice to have a place to go where you aren't surrounded by that."
The store also has a wall of Elvis prayers where shoppers tack up pleas to the King.
Even though Cameron is no longer the store's owner, he said, it's important that the shop remain family-owned.
"I do think that if Wendy and Bridget hadn't wanted the store, I would have closed it," he said.
Cameron enjoys the store even more now that he is no longer its owner and said he is confident that Smith and McMillan are managing the shop well.
"I'd been out of town, and when I walked back in the store, I felt like the proud papa," he said. "To me, it's better than it's ever been. It's just such a thrill for me to see my baby in their hands."
Contact the Features Editor at features@unc.edu.