The Daily Tar Heel
Printing news. Raising hell. Since 1893.
Sunday, May 5, 2024 Newsletters Latest print issue

We keep you informed.

Help us keep going. Donate Today.
The Daily Tar Heel

Column: Trying out the new Old Chicago

spent the first 15 years of my life living just outside of Boston, Mass., which, in effect, makes me a Northerner. Every once in a while, people will ask me what I miss the most about living up north.

I’ll think about it for a few minutes, and then with full confidence I will say, “the food.”

Although Southern fried chicken and grits have their merits, nothing truly compares to a hearty northern bagel or an authentic New England Italian cannoli, or — dare I say — a real New York slice of pizza. Praise the food gods for blessing us with such a miracle!

So, as a fairly harsh critic, my expectations were set extra high walking into Chapel Hill’s newest pizza and beer location, Old Chicago Pizza and Taproom.

Upon first entering the restaurant just off of Church Street, you’ll notice how the facility is unexpectedly large. Dining tables and booths take up almost one half of the area, while the other half is occupied by a lengthy bar top and several raised tables with stools.

A particularly interesting feature is its garage door style windows located on the back wall behind the bar. These windows can be raised to create an island bar setup so that people sitting outside can be served at the bar without ever having to walk through a door.

Raising these windows effectively doubles the bar space available, which greatly reduces the number of thirsty people cluttered around, making it easier for customers to get a drink.

Their beer selection is extensive. The full page menu categorizes their entire selection by type and taste, so that customers can try new products that sound appealing and also have an idea of what to expect.

However, I’ve found the menu can be overwhelming and intimidating for those of us who aren’t your everyday beer connoisseurs — I’m still struggling with what it means to have “floral notes” in my drink.

Unfortunately, the staff is new, and they make it abundantly clear. The night I went, there were three times as many bartenders as anywhere else on Franklin Street, yet somehow it took three times as long to be served. I wouldn’t count it against them though, since the establishment has only been operating for a couple weeks, and I’m sure most are first-time bartenders.

The shining star and greatest selling point that this place offers has got to be its late night $2 personal pizza special. Drunken customers are invited to come any time between 10 p.m. and closing to satisfy their midnight munchies.

The pizza itself is not the best tasting slice I’ve ever had, but compared to other options found here in the South, it tastes pretty great. I forged myself a mushroom and bacon masterpiece, and consumed every last bite.

I have a feeling this place will become a Tar Heel staple in due time. It has one of the best locations in the area, impressive food, a wide variety of drinks and lots of public attention. I look forward to seeing how they do over the next few months.

To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.