But only one got to redeem himself for his missed kicks.
After his penalty kick was stopped in the 71st minute, UNC forward Mike Gell rebounded by scoring the game's lone goal in the 95th minute. The strike gave UNC a 1-0 overtime victory in the third round of the NCAA Tournament.
Gell had four shots on goal against the Eagles, including a first-period blast that was knocked away by American goalkeeper Michael Behonick.
But he shook off the earlier misses and got open in the box during the overtime period. David Testo sent it into Gell, who then split two defenders and beat Behonick to the near post.
"I was just so happy for the seniors and to make up for the penalty kick, of course," Gell said. "It was great. I had so many chances, so it made me want to work that much harder to get it through the net."
After a handball by an American player in the box, UNC got a penalty kick. Gell said he looked around at his teammates and saw most of them standing around, so he decided to take the shot.
Gell chose to hit it low and left, but Behonick guessed right and slapped the shot away.
It was Gell's first penalty kick as a Tar Heel, but the decision of who shoots them is one Bolowich said he has always left up to his players.
"I've always thought that you don't pick somebody and put the pressure on them if they're not ready," Bolowich said.