The Daily Tar Heel
Printing news. Raising hell. Since 1893.
Monday, April 29, 2024 Newsletters Latest print issue

We keep you informed.

Help us keep going. Donate Today.
The Daily Tar Heel

Column: Migrants are not modern barbaroi

Colin Kantor

Columnist Colin Kantor

When you think of the word “barbarian,” perhaps you conjure an image of an intimidating warrior, dressed in animal skins and wielding an axe, ready to burn and pillage some unsuspecting civilized town.

The term “barbarian” is an etymologically interesting one, with origins in the ancient Greek “barbaros.” This term denoted someone who did not speak Greek, as the Greeks thought foreigners merely made stammering sounds to the effect of “bar-bar-bar.”

As a marker of identification, it was pejoratively used not only to characterize non-Greeks but also those who some Greeks considered “not Greek enough.” One notable example was the peoples of Macedonia, the northern region where Alexander the Great was born.

Of course, calling Alexander and his people “barbarians” did not stop the brilliant young general from conquering all of Greece and then much of the Persian Empire in less than twenty years, spreading a form of Greek culture called Hellenism and leaving a cultural legacy that would last centuries.

Whether or not Alexander was a “true” Greek, his contributions to Greek culture are indisputable. This example demonstrates the related and problematic concept of xenophobia.

In the past few weeks, issues of xenophobia have come to a head in Europe, which is currently facing an unprecedented migration crisis.

On Aug. 21, the Republic of Macedonia closed its border crossing with Greece, citing its inability to deal with an influx of thousands of migrants, many fleeing conflicts in the Middle East like the Syrian Civil War. After Europe was shocked by a crackdown involving heavily armed police facing down unarmed migrants and their crying, the border crossing reopened two days later.

Just last week, the bodies of 71 migrants were discovered in an abandoned truck on an Austrian highway near Vienna, just as European leaders were preparing to meet to discuss a unified response to the crisis. These deaths are only a handful of the thousands of migrant deaths so far this year.

At best, these migrants have been targets for European xenophobia; at worst, they have been written off as “barbarians.” While leaders like German Chancellor Angela Merkel have said Europe should keep an open mind about offering asylum to refugees, the rising popularity of some anti-immigrant parties would suggest a greater disparity in political discourse.

Today’s migrants may not speak a European language, but that is no excuse to characterize them as simply the newest wave of “barbarians.”

It is morally objectionable to continue the policy of “othering,” whether it happens in Europe or in our own backyard.

I study languages out of a desire to appreciate other cultures, and I believe a lack of understanding of the contributing factors has engendered the current situation.

David Miliband, president of the International Rescue Committee, neatly summed the problem up: “By the time ships are pulling bodies from the Mediterranean, it is too late.”

To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.