Lt. Josh Mecimore, spokesperson for the Chapel Hill Police Department, said although the cemetery is surrounded by UNC’s campus, it became city property in 1987.
“While the Old Chapel Hill cemetery falls within the city limits of Chapel Hill, and it’s owned by the town of Chapel Hill, the Department of Public Safety typically responds to calls that occur there,” he said. “They will usually alert us to the calls as well.”
History professor Harry Watson said the decision for jurisdiction over the cemetery came down to who would have to pay to get the grass cut. He said UNC questioned why it kept up a cemetery when it was primarily a university.
Watson said there are several “unique inscriptions” on headstones in the cemetery.
An epitaph on Jane Gilbert’s headstone reads, “I was a Tar Heel born and a Tar Heel bred/and here I lie a Tar Heel dead.”
Watson said another inscription was made by Cornelia Phillips Spencer, a prominent white woman who helped UNC open during Reconstruction.
It was made for her black servant who was formerly her family’s slave. The final line reads, “Well done my good and faithful servant.”
Watson said it wasn’t clear if this is the inscription the woman’s family would have chosen for her.
The cemetery is divided into several sections including dividing white people and black people.
“If it’s historically segregated that’s just a fact of history, but if it’s still happening today then that’s really a problem,” senior Dylan Blackwell said. “I think people that are already buried and have chosen to be buried that way, we shouldn’t tamper with that.”
Watson said it’s rare for people to tamper with graves.
“I think, by and large, people don’t mess with cemeteries,” Watson said. “I think there’s a widespread belief that cemeteries should not be disturbed.”
To get the day's news and headlines in your inbox each morning, sign up for our email newsletters.
Janice Ezenwa, a sophomore, visited the cemetery after her professor advised her class to. She said she knew the cemetery was segregated.
“I don’t see why they would move the bodies, I mean, now they’re all resting there,” she said. “They should just leave it.”
Lane said the cemetery is nothing to be afraid of.
“I think most of the imagination comes from people themselves, but it’s nothing really scary about the cemetery out there, it’s a lot of history out there,” Lane said.
“Dean Smith’s out there. Could you just imagine him scaring somebody? No, I don’t think so.”